Blue Moon Ice Cream is a vibrant, sky-blue dessert with a whimsical, fruity flavor that’s captured the hearts of ice cream lovers, particularly in the Midwest. Its unique taste—often described as a dreamy mix of vanilla, raspberry, and a hint of citrus—makes it a nostalgic treat for many. With the help of the Ninja Creami, you can now recreate this iconic scoop at home with ease. The result is a smooth, creamy, and colorful dessert that’s both fun to make and delicious to enjoy.

Full Recipe:

Ingredients

1½ cups whole milk
4 tablespoons instant vanilla pudding mix
½ cup heavy cream
1 teaspoon raspberry extract
½ teaspoon lemon extract
15–20 drops blue food coloring

Directions

In a mixing bowl, whisk together the milk and vanilla pudding mix until fully dissolved.
Stir in the heavy cream, raspberry extract, and lemon extract.
Add blue food coloring, drop by drop, until you reach your desired shade.
Pour the mixture into a Ninja Creami pint container, ensuring it stays below the max fill line.
Secure the lid and freeze on a flat surface for at least 24 hours.
After freezing, remove the lid and place the pint into the Ninja Creami.
Select the “Ice Cream” function to process the mixture.
If the texture is crumbly, use the “Re-spin” function. For extra creaminess, add a tablespoon of milk and spin again.
Serve immediately and enjoy your homemade Blue Moon Ice Cream.

Nutrients

Per serving (½ cup, approximate):

Calories: 200 kcal
Total Fat: 12 g
Saturated Fat: 7 g
Cholesterol: 45 mg
Sodium: 60 mg
Carbohydrates: 20 g
Sugars: 18 g
Protein: 3 g

The Allure of the Blue Moon Flavor

One of the most intriguing aspects of Blue Moon Ice Cream is its flavor. Unlike traditional flavors such as chocolate or vanilla, Blue Moon resists easy classification. Descriptions range from hints of raspberry and citrus to subtle vanilla and almond notes. Some even compare its flavor to marshmallow cereal milk or fruity bubblegum. Its true recipe remains somewhat of a mystery, with variations depending on the brand or creator. This ambiguity only adds to its appeal—it’s an experience, not just a taste. The flavor is simultaneously nostalgic and novel, making it a conversation starter and a crowd-pleaser.

A Midwest Classic with Mysterious Origins

While its exact origins are hard to pinpoint, Blue Moon Ice Cream has deep roots in the American Midwest. It’s especially popular in states like Wisconsin and Michigan, where it’s a staple in regional ice cream shops. For decades, locals have associated it with summer traditions, from lakeside vacations to family outings at the ice cream stand. Some say it originated in Milwaukee or Chicago, but its creator remains unknown. Despite—or perhaps because of—its elusive past, Blue Moon continues to win hearts and taste buds across generations.

Why the Color Matters

The vivid blue color of this ice cream is one of its most striking features. It’s not just for show; the color evokes a playful, dreamy mood that aligns with the name “Blue Moon.” For children, the hue is exciting and magical. For adults, it recalls carefree days of youth. Visually, it stands out in any ice cream case or dessert table. The color alone makes it Instagram-worthy and a popular choice for parties, birthday celebrations, and nostalgic events. In homemade versions, achieving that signature look with food coloring adds an element of creative fun to the process.

Modern Take with the Ninja Creami

The Ninja Creami has revolutionized homemade ice cream making. Unlike traditional churn methods, the Creami allows for a smoother, faster preparation process, especially for those who may not have experience making frozen desserts from scratch. For a recipe like Blue Moon Ice Cream, it offers consistent texture and the ability to experiment with different bases and flavors. The Creami is particularly useful for those who want a dense, creamy result that mimics store-bought quality. It makes the process approachable and rewarding, allowing home cooks to create restaurant-style ice cream without needing an ice cream machine.

Family-Friendly Fun in the Kitchen

Making Blue Moon Ice Cream at home is not just about the final product—it’s an engaging activity for families. Children love watching the transformation from a colorful liquid base to a frozen treat. They can participate in choosing the amount of coloring, naming the flavor they think it resembles, or even customizing their own mix-ins. It encourages hands-on creativity in the kitchen, helps teach basic cooking skills, and brings family members together around a shared, joyful project. It’s an ideal weekend or summer afternoon activity that ends with a sweet reward.

Endless Customization Possibilities

Although the classic Blue Moon flavor is delicious on its own, the recipe offers plenty of room for personalization. You can mix in marshmallows, white chocolate chips, or crushed cereal to enhance the flavor and texture. Some prefer adding a swirl of raspberry jam or lemon zest to deepen the fruity profile. If you’re serving it for a party, try topping it with whipped cream and sprinkles to increase its visual appeal. The Ninja Creami also allows for “re-spinning,” so you can adjust the texture or blend in new ingredients even after the first cycle. This flexibility makes it a go-to dessert for experimenting with new ideas.

A Conversation Starter at Any Event

Serving Blue Moon Ice Cream at events is guaranteed to generate buzz. Its color and elusive flavor spark curiosity, making guests ask, “What flavor is this?” It’s ideal for themed parties—especially ones involving space, unicorns, or fantasy elements. Kids adore it for the fun factor, and adults love the nostalgic throwback. It can be scooped into cones, layered into sundaes, or even sandwiched between cookies for a vibrant twist on the traditional ice cream sandwich. Its cheerful aesthetic makes it more than a dessert—it’s an experience.

A Dessert That Transcends Age

Although it may seem tailored for children, Blue Moon Ice Cream has just as much appeal for adults. Its balance of fruity and creamy notes creates a complex flavor profile that isn’t overly sweet. The nostalgic element strikes a chord with those who grew up enjoying the flavor during summer trips or ice cream socials. And for those trying it for the first time, it offers something delightfully different from the usual chocolate and vanilla. It manages to be both whimsical and refined, making it suitable for a wide range of palates.

How It Compares to Traditional Ice Cream Flavors

Blue Moon stands apart from traditional ice cream flavors because it offers both familiarity and mystery. Unlike chocolate, strawberry, or mint, which have clear expectations, Blue Moon is always a bit of a surprise. That makes it especially appealing for adventurous eaters or anyone bored with the basics. It also pairs surprisingly well with other flavors. A scoop of Blue Moon alongside a scoop of lemon, raspberry, or vanilla makes for a visually stunning and flavorful dessert plate. The contrast in color and taste adds depth and interest to the typical ice cream serving.

Ideal for Special Occasions

From baby showers to birthday parties, Blue Moon Ice Cream can be the highlight of a dessert table. Its bright hue fits well with celebratory themes, and its uniqueness ensures it won’t be forgotten. You can make a large batch in advance and store it in the freezer until it’s time to serve. Presented in clear cups, waffle cones, or colorful bowls, it elevates any gathering with its charm. Consider pairing it with color-coordinated décor for an even more immersive experience—blue napkins, themed toppings, and matching drinks can complete the look.

Health and Ingredient Awareness

While Blue Moon Ice Cream is a treat, it can be made with attention to dietary preferences. You can use lower-fat milk or dairy alternatives like oat or almond milk. Sugar content can be moderated, and extracts can be selected based on quality and concentration. Homemade versions give you full control over what goes in—no preservatives, artificial stabilizers, or unnecessary additives. For those with allergies, it’s easy to swap ingredients as needed, making it a safer choice than some store-bought options.

Easy to Store and Serve

Another great benefit of Blue Moon Ice Cream made with the Ninja Creami is how well it stores. You can prepare multiple pints and freeze them in advance, making it easy to serve dessert on short notice. The Creami’s re-spin feature also ensures that the texture remains smooth even after a few days in the freezer. This makes it ideal for those who like to plan ahead or keep a few treats on hand for guests or late-night cravings.

Creative Presentation Ideas

Presentation adds an extra element of fun to Blue Moon Ice Cream. Serve it in glass dessert cups with layers of whipped cream, fruit, or colorful toppings. Add edible glitter or candy stars for a magical, space-themed treat. For a summer twist, turn it into popsicles or blend it into a blue milkshake. You can also incorporate it into layered parfaits, float-style beverages, or ice cream cakes. The possibilities are endless, and the visual appeal is always a highlight.

Conclusion

Blue Moon Ice Cream is more than a dessert—it’s a playful, colorful expression of joy and nostalgia. Its unique flavor profile, striking appearance, and mysterious roots make it one of the most fun and memorable frozen treats to serve and enjoy. With tools like the Ninja Creami, it’s never been easier to bring this classic into your own kitchen and share it with family and friends.

Pin6

6 Shares